Keep Your Rental or Sell Calculator

Request your offer today

By requesting an offer you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Keep Your Rental or Sell Calculator

See what your rental may leave each year and what a sale could free up.

Before you start

Cash flow is not taxable income.

Sale cash shown here is before income tax.

Loading your tool...

Start with rent you can expect to collect

Use the current lease and recent records. Do not assume every month will bring full rent forever. Add a line for time without a tenant or rent you may not collect.

If rent is below the amount shown in local ads, do not replace it with the higher amount at once. The current lease, local rules, and real demand may affect a change. Test a new-rent plan on its own.

Build a yearly cash-flow sheet

Cash flow means cash coming in, less cash going out. For planning, also set money aside for future work. A reserve is money held for that purpose.

Yearly lineMade-up example
Rent if every month is paid$26,400
Less allowance for missed rent or vacancy$1,320
Less tax, insurance, dues, management, and other running costs$7,800
Less routine repair budget$1,800
Less reserve for major work$1,500
Less loan principal and interest payments$7,200
Planned cash left$6,780

The sample starts at $2,200 in rent each month. Every figure is made up. The vacancy allowance is not a suggested rate for your rental. Use your history and a reasonable range.

Check that tax and insurance are not counted twice through escrow. In this table, loan payments include principal and interest only. Tax and insurance sit in the running-cost line.

Keep this separate from taxable income

The cash sheet includes principal payments and reserves. Tax rules treat some items differently. The IRS rental-property guide explains rental expenses and depreciation. Depreciation spreads certain property costs across tax years.

Do not copy the cash total onto a tax form. Ask your tax professional to use the actual records. The two totals may be different even when both are correct.

Estimate the cash a sale would release

Start with a supported sale estimate or a written offer. Subtract sale costs, buyer credits, repairs you would pay for, and the loan payoff. Include any other amount that must be paid at closing.

For a made-up example, use a $230,000 price, $15,000 in sale costs, and a $100,000 payoff. That leaves $115,000 before income tax. It is not $115,000 of taxable profit.

Give your tax professional the purchase records, past improvements, depreciation records, and sale estimate. The IRS guide to selling business and rental assets covers the rules that may affect the tax result. Keep an estimated tax reserve separate until it is checked.

Compare a year's cash with the cash tied up

In the sample, divide $6,780 of planned yearly cash by $115,000 of possible sale cash. The result is about 5.9%.

This is a simple comparison, not the rental's full return. It leaves out future price changes, tax effects, and the value of principal paid down. It also leaves out what another use of the money might earn or cost.

Ask what you would do with the sale cash. Paying off costly debt, buying another property, and holding cash are different choices. Compare the risks and the time each one needs.

Test the plan when things go wrong

  • More vacancy: One more missed $2,200 rent payment cuts the sample cash left to $4,580.
  • A large bill: A repair that costs $6,000 beyond the amount set aside cuts it to $780.
  • A lower sale price: A $10,000 price drop cuts sale cash by about $10,000 before any linked fee change.

Do not use these cases to scare yourself into a sale. Use them to see how much room your plan has. A strong rental can still be a poor fit if it needs cash or time you cannot spare.

Add the work that does not appear on the sheet

Note your hours, travel, stress, and ability to fund the next major repair. Also note what you value about keeping the property. You do not need to force these items into a dollar score to make them count.

If selling is one option, ask Frontdoor about an offer for the rental. Compare the written terms with the cost of keeping it. Use current numbers, and keep room for what is still unknown.

Common questions

Is this my rental's total return?

No. The cash comparison leaves out future price changes, taxes, and the value of principal paid down. It shows one part of the choice.

Why count money set aside for repairs?

That cash may be needed for later work. Setting it aside helps you avoid treating all current cash as money you can spend.

Should I sell if the rental cash flow is low?

The tool does not make that choice. Review the taxes, expected work, risks, and what you would do with the sale cash.

Sources

More tools for your next step

Request an offer review

Share details about the home and your plans. We will review the facts and explain any offer we can make. Compare the terms before you decide.

Get Offer
By requesting an offer you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.
Offer Requested!

Just sell.
Simple. Done.

Tell us about the home and when you hope to move. We will review the facts and explain any offer we can make. Read the terms before you choose.

Offer Requested!