Cash Offer vs. Listing Calculator

Request your offer today

By requesting an offer you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Cash Offer vs. Listing Calculator

Your home. Your numbers.

Compare your sale paths

Start with the prices and costs you have.

Fill in each path you want to compare. Use 0 only for a known zero cost.

List as-isNot started
List as-is

Use an estimated sale price for this route.

Use the fees in your own agreement.
Leave out cuts already included in the sale price.
Do not count the same credit twice.
Match the closing date. Leave blank if payoff is 0.
Include repairs, bills, and full loan payments. Use a later payoff that reflects principal paid.
For example: agent estimate or lender quote.
Fix and listNot started
Fix and list

Use an estimated sale price for this route.

Use the fees in your own agreement.
Leave out cuts already included in the sale price.
Do not count the same credit twice.
Match the closing date. Leave blank if payoff is 0.
Include repairs, bills, and full loan payments. Use a later payoff that reflects principal paid.
For example: agent estimate or lender quote.
Cash offerNot started
Cash offer
An online home value is not an offer.
Use the fees in your own agreement.
Leave out cuts already included in the sale price.
Do not count the same credit twice.
Match the closing date. Leave blank if payoff is 0.
Include repairs, bills, and full loan payments. Use a later payoff that reflects principal paid.
For example: agent estimate or lender quote.

Count escrow payments and known refunds. Do not also subtract bills paid from that escrow. Results are before income tax.

No email needed. This calculator does not send or save your entries.

For each number, add its source and date. For example: agent estimate, written repair quote, lender payoff, or your best guess. Write “unknown” when you still need a fact. Unknown is not the same as zero.

Read your sale comparison

Cash at closing means the sale price, minus the amounts taken out at closing, plus any credits owed to you. Ask the closing company for a draft list. Add each charge once.

Use the agent fees in your own agreement. Do not assume there is one required rate. The National Association of Realtors explains that agent pay is negotiable.

Use the payoff for the right date

Your loan balance may not be the amount needed to pay off the loan. A payoff can include interest through a set date and other amounts due. Request it from your lender or loan servicer. The CFPB explains the difference between balance and payoff.

Use a payoff for each possible closing date. If you make loan payments while you wait, part may reduce the debt. The later payoff must reflect that. Do not subtract those payments and also use the old debt balance.

Count the cash you spend before the sale

Keep a second list for repairs, cleaning, loan payments, bills, and other cash paid while you wait. These costs may not appear on the closing sheet. They still affect how much cash the sale leaves you.

Subtract those cash outlays from cash at closing. Add any known refund paid later. A refund of your own escrow money is not new profit. Keep that line visible.

Check your loan statement for escrow. This account may hold money for tax and insurance bills. For this cash sheet, count escrow payments and any refund. Do not also subtract the bills paid from escrow. If the refund is unknown, keep it separate until you can check it.

A worked example

These numbers are made up. They are not offers, local price estimates, or standard fees. This example has no escrow account. Taxes and insurance are paid directly. Each payoff reflects the planned loan payments.

ItemCash offerList as-isFix and list
Price$250,000$275,000$300,000
Sale costs and credits$1,500$16,875$17,700
Loan payoff$140,350$139,300$139,000
Cash at closing$108,150$118,825$143,300
Cash spent before closing$500$6,000$32,000
Net cash$107,650$112,825$111,300
Assumed days to close1590120

In this example, listing as-is leaves the most cash. It leaves $1,525 more than fixing and listing. The cash offer has the shortest assumed time. Those are two useful facts. Neither decides which path fits your needs.

Check what could change the result

  • What if the listing sells for less?
  • What if repairs cost more or take longer?
  • Which buyer costs are still unknown?
  • Can you pay the bills before the sale?
  • Do the contract terms support your move date?

This sheet does not work out income taxes or your tax profit. Use your records and a tax professional for that step. A small gap between two choices may disappear when an estimate changes.

Bring the comparison to Frontdoor

Want a sale option to compare with your plan? Request an offer from Frontdoor. Share the property details and the date you have in mind. Ask which costs and terms apply to that offer. Add the written numbers to your sheet before you choose.

Common questions

Is a cash offer always less than a listing price?

No fixed gap applies to every home. Compare a written offer with a supported sale estimate, then subtract each path's real costs.

Is cash at closing the same as profit?

No. It is the cash left on the closing sheet. Repairs and other costs paid earlier may still reduce what you keep. Tax profit is a separate calculation.

What if I do not know a cost?

Leave it blank until you can check it. Zero means there is no charge. A blank means the amount still needs work.

Sources

More tools for your next step

Request an offer review

Share details about the home and your plans. We will review the facts and explain any offer we can make. Compare the terms before you decide.

Get Offer
By requesting an offer you're confirming that you agree with our Terms and Conditions.
Offer Requested!

Just sell.
Simple. Done.

Tell us about the home and when you hope to move. We will review the facts and explain any offer we can make. Read the terms before you choose.

Offer Requested!